I did’t know what to talk about on the blog so Chris suggested I do a cost analysis for our minivan. I can do that!
Trip | Frequency | Km per year | Alternative |
---|---|---|---|
Skiing | 130km 15 times per year | 1,950 km | car share |
Spinning, hockey and fitness classes | 30km twice per week | 3,120 km | Car pool and car share |
Grocery shopping | 10km once per week | 520 km | Bike, car share |
General shopping | 40km once per month | 480 km | Bus, bike, car share |
Visiting (Montreal etc…) | 400km once every two months plus 40km per month | 2,640 km | Car share |
Vacations | 1200km once per year and 600km three times per year | 4,800 km | car share, car rental |
Kids activities in bad weather | 5km once per week for 20 weeks | 100 km | Snowsuits! |
Total | 13,710 km |
With this mileage, and not including the cost of the van itself, the yearly price tag for operating our van, including gas, insurance and maintenance is $5,300. The same trips with VRTUCAR car share would set us back about $6,000. Apart from the cost, the closest depot is in Britannia which would be quite a trip to make twice a week.
Overall, with our current trip frequency, and the fact that every once in a while we do use a van in a way we just could not use a car (like talking the whole family and all our bikes somewhere) car share is not attractive at all.
On the other hand, getting rid of the second car and switching both of our work commutes to bike/bus combination saves us well over $1,000 per year amongst all other benefits.